My Favourite Detectives from the Bookish World
My Favourite Detectives from the Bookish World who made me fall in love with thrillers
It is said, that books are a man’s best friend and I feel that this statement is 100% correct. My love for books started when I was just a small girl. Every year, when my parents bought books for the new school session, I would be too excited. The moment we reached home, I started reading the stories in my Bengali and English textbooks. By the time school started, I would have finished reading all the stories at least twice.
As I grew older and got introduced to comics and other stories written for kids, my passion for reading fantasy and comedy tales also increased.
Although I did not realize it then, I was especially fond of reading stories that had an element of thrill and suspense in them. However, it was only in the fifth grade that my father, introduced me to the world of novels. He simply handed me a thriller novel Pandav Goyenda by Sasthipada Chattopadhyay. He said I should stop reading comics and start reading something more interesting.
It was the first detective novel I had ever read. Reading the book gave rise to an unquenchable thirst for thrillers in my heart. Even during my college days, when my girlfriends were smitten with the romantic tales of Mills & Boons, I was in love with the thrill and excitement of detective novels. My love for this genre has only deepened over the years, and during this time, I have also developed a list of my favorite detectives from the bookish world. So here are my top-loved fictional detectives who have kept me entertained over the years.
Feluda by Satyajit Ray
Feluda is a fictional detective character created by none other than the great writer-director Satyajit Ray. Undoubtedly, Feluda is one of the finest creations of Satyajit Ray. Coming from a Bengali background, the detective uses the name Feluda as an alias. His real name is Pradosh Chandra Mitra, and he is assisted in his investigations by his two sidekicks Jatayu and Topshe. Ray introduced Feluda as a next-door guy, and that gave a realistic feel to the character. In 1965, Feluda’s first story (Feludar Goendagiri) was published in one of the leading Bengali children’s magazines Sandesh.
In no time, Feluda won the hearts of readers in the age bracket of 8 to 80 years. Ray illustrated Feluda as a young man roughly 27 years old (1938 born) and 6’ in height. He is brilliant in analytical and observation skills. In addition to this, he is excellent in martial arts.
Feluda, is strongly inspired by Sherlock Holmes. The character shares various similarities with the fictional legend. What appeals to me most about Feluda is that he is extremely choosy about which cases he accepts. He prefers the ones that are intriguing and require strong intellect rather than physical strength. Many of the Feluda stories, were made as Bengali movies by Satyajit Ray himself. ‘Sonar Kella’ is one of the initial releases of the Feluda series as a film.
Hercule Poirot by Agatha Christie
This fictional Belgian detective stole my heart. He was the creation of the famous British writer Agatha Christie. Poirot was featured in 33 novels and 51 short stories penned by the author. He was also featured in 2 plays written by Agatha Christie. Poirot’s popularity is second only to Sherlock Holmes, and his remarkable intelligence is what made him so successful in his field. His background as a police detective helped him significantly in solving cases.
Poirot is one of the longest-running fictional detectives and has a more laid-back and introverted persona. I love his signature curly moustache, as it adds a unique style to his personality. His complete faith in his instinct and brilliance in noticing even the minute details have contributed significantly to his success. His first appearance happened with the book The Mysterious Affair at Styles in 1920.
The Hardy Boys – Edward Stratemeyer
I first started reading the Hardy Boys series when I was in my early teenage years. The characters and book series were created by Edward Stratemeyer. He was the founder of Stratemeyer Syndicate. The fact that brothers Frank and Joe Hard were teenagers, and that played an important role in attracting me to the series. What do I most like about them? It was that despite being amateur detectives, they did not miss even the smallest detail while solving a case. It helped them to stump even highly experienced professionals in the field.
Most importantly, the brothers never seemed to get afraid of the risk involved in dealing with nasty villains and hardened criminals. The Hardy Boys are also part of the video game world. Isn’t that interesting to see their journey from book to silver screen and then also in the video games world.
Nancy Drew -Edward Stratemeyer
I started reading Nancy Drew while I was still enjoying the action and adventure of the Hardy Boys series. The series was the brainchild of Edward Stratemeyer, so I was sure that I would find it appealing. Stratemeyer had created the character of Nancy Drew as a female counterpart of Hardy Boys. Even though the format of the books in the Nancy Drew series was somewhat similar to that of the Hardy Boys series, her method of solving cases was quite different.
Stratmeyer presented her as an attractive and amazingly talented young woman. Nancy loved to solve mysteries when she was still a teenager. I was impressed and inspired by her cool attitude and sweet yet strong personality. As any parent, do you wish to introduce thriller mystery books to your kids? If yes, you can surely start with Nancy Drew. Young kids will love reading such thriller stories.
Sherlock Holmes– Arthur Conan Doyle
I think there is hardly any lover of the thriller genre who does not adore Sherlock Holmes. Many even believe that the renowned British author, Arthur Conan Doyle based the character on an actual person. I simply love the unique manner in which he investigates each case, which many feel borders on eccentric. However, his excellent skills of observation and deduction, combined with his knowledge of forensic science and logical reasoning make him one of the most successful detectives in the literary world.
He is assisted in his detective work by his friend and housemate, Dr. Watson. His popularity can be gauged by the fact that dozens of TV shows and several movies have been made, featuring his cases. A Study In Scarlet was the first book published of Sherlock Holmes in 1887. I started my Sherlock Holmes journey with Bengali translated books and then later moved to English versions.
Byomkesh Bakshi -Sharadindu Bandyopadhyay
It would not be wrong to say that writer Sharadindu Bandyopadhyay based his detective character of Byomkesh Bakshi on Sherlock Homes. He has the same observation and deduction skills and holds significant knowledge of forensic science. However, this did not in any way, diminish my pleasure in reading about his unique style of investigation and skills in solving even the most complex cases. Like most other detectives, Byomkesh is assisted in his quests by his sidekick Ajit Kumar. He refers to himself as “Satyanweshi”, which means “seeker of truth”. Later his wife Satyabati also played a significant role by assisting Byomkesh with her intellect.
The popularity of Byomkesh as a detective extends beyond the literal world. That is why multiple series and movies featuring the character in the lead role have been produced and directed to date. Just like Feluda, several movies are adapted based on the stories of Byomkesh Bakshi. Its true majority are Bengali films, and only 1 so far made in Hindi which cast late actor Sushant Rajpoot as Byomkesh Bakshi.
Miss Marple -Agatha Christie
Miss Marple changed my perception of a good detective completely. This fictional detective, created by Agatha Christie, is an elderly lady who never married. She is an amateur detective, who solves some of the most difficult crimes using her shrewd intelligence.
Miss Marple is a brilliant listener and can connect any casual comments made by people around her with the cases she is working on. She was featured in 20 short stories and 12 novels penned by Agatha Christie. Her image of an old spinster hides her character as a smart sleuth remarkably well.
Wrapping up
All detectives featured above have taught me something new about human behaviour. Even though all of them are fictional, they constantly inspire me to think outside the box and look beyond what is apparent. Thrillers are something which make my brain do the maximum exercise to identify the culprit well before the climax.
“This post is part of the Bookish League blog hop hosted by Bohemian Bibliophile“
Oh, these are all my favorites too
Esp Hardy Boys and Sherlock 😍
Among all the great fictional detective characters that you have listed – my list of favorites also features Sherlock holmes, Hercules Poirot,Ms. Marple and our very own Felu Da Parry Mason is one more character that I quite liked though he was a lawyer but thought like a detective,
Poirot is a favorite of mine too. Love Agatha Christie too.
Ahhh! Love this post! Really took me back to my childhood! My father STILL talks about Hardy Boys. The only group I now additionally of is Famous Five! I enjoyed those books so much too!
Great post! Agatha Christie’s Poirot( as well as David Suchet playing him on the screen, Nancy Drew( as well as the movie on Amazon Prime adapted from these stories), Sherlock Holmes ( including the Benedict Cumberbatch remakes) and so many others are unforgettable and timeless.
Feluda and Byomkesh live with the blood and soul of every Bengali.. There’s hardly a bengali household that doesn’t have at least one book of them. I grew up reading Feluda and Kakababu.. I often imagined myself as an assistant of Kakababu and Santu.
Oh God, I haven’t read any of these. But really enjoyed watching Byomkesh Bakshi on Doordarshan. And I love your creative posters! It makes this post look so smart and organised.
This was such a fun post. I started out thinking I’d know none of the characters since thrillers aren’t my favourite genre but then I found so many old friends -Poirot, Hardy Boys, Nancy Drew, Miss Marple. I really need to get to Feluda. I haven’t read any of his adventures and he keeps coming up in discussions. Thanks for that nudge.
Except Feluda, I know all the rest. I haven’t read Byomkesh’s stories as they are in Bengali. But I got to know about him recently, so will be watching the movies on him.
Byomkesh Baksi and hercule poirot are my fav too. recently I read kanpur khufiya series by Richa S Mukherjee and I liked her detective character Prachand Tripathi too. very Indianized and reatable.
Oh, I grew up reading Nancy Drew and Feluda and now my kids love this genre. Hardy Boys is another favorite in our home. Great compilation!
It goes without saying that I absolutely love Nancy Drew and Hardy Boys. I watched the series also on YouTube during Covid-19. I can never get enough of them and their bravado. However, I have never read a book on Feluda, so that goes on my list. Sherlock and Mrs Marple are awesome. I need to revive my memories of Poirot though.
Other than Feluda by Satyajit Ray I have read and loved all the detectives that you have listed here. I really like mystery books and thrillers, it keeps me hooked till the very end! Now I shall be on the look out for Feluda by Satyajit Ray too…
I totally agree with your list thought I haven’t read any byomkesh will definitely get down to it soon
My fav will always be poiroit and if I can add to this list it would be Philip Marlowe by Raymond Chandler
I’m reminded of my childhood, I used to do the same thing of reading all the stories in my English and Hindi textbooks! I LOVE thrillers, I’ve read almost all the series you mentioned although I haven’t read all the books in the Feluda adventures. My mom introduced me to Feluda and Hardy BOys although I only read one or two of the Hardy Boys, I much preferred Nancy Drew 🙂
Hardy Boys, Sherlock Holmes and Nancy Drew give me major nostalgia. But nothing can take the place of Poirot. I am a solid fan of Poirot. I have watched a movie on Byomkesh Bakshi but never read him though. And Miss Marple is one character I totally missed out on. Trying her now.
Reading this post took me to my growing years. It was the world of the Famous Five and Five Find Outers of Enid Blyton. The young heart raced with excitement as the adventures of the Hard Boys unfolded. Later the eccentric genius of Sherlock Holmes and Hercule Poirot, had me in raptures.
Feluda and Poirot are all-time favourites. This post brought back lovely memories of devouring Nancy Drew and Hardy Boys back in school.
Good one. I admire how intellectually you analysed the characters and find out as your fav. detectives. Sherlock Holmes and Byomesh Bakshi are my favourties also.
Ah I spot most of my favorites in your compilation. I loved Nancy drew and Sherlock Holmes. I recently got bYOmkesh bakshi translation will look forward to read
So many favourites in your list. Grew up on a steady diet of Hardy Boys and Nancy Drew. A Feluda book, won as a prize, made him my favourite Indian detectective. Byomkesh Bakshi I remember from a TV series on Doordarshan
Lovely compilation! Nancy Drew is a favorite, as are the Famous Five; none of my book shopping hauls are complete without getting one of these.
Though I am not so good fan of thriller novels. I find them so gripping and fascinating. Believe it or not, I have read every single book in the list. Wish to read few from your recommendation.
Oh! That is an extensive list of thriller heroes in the fiction thriller world. I find my favourites too in the list. Starting from Hercule Poirot, Sherlock Homes, and Miss Maples. I have only heard of the Bengali characters, not read or watched them in action.
Agree with you. All the detectives you’ve mentioned are my favorite too. have grown up watching Byomkesh Bakshi and Feluda and hence they are my most favorites.
Oh! You chose such an interesting topic to write about! Brought back so many memories of reading Nancy Drew and Hardy Boys. Though I never read Byomkesh Bakshi but didn’t ever miss a single episode of the tv series. Thanks for this wonderful post!
Feluda is the only one I have not read from your list. Enjoyed the list 🙂
Sherlock was, is and will always be my favorite for all seasons! But reading about all the other popular detectives is equally engrossing.
From this list, the only detective whose stories I’ve never read are Byomkesh Bakshi, though of course I’m familiar with him. But I’m sure you already know my absolute topmost favourite – Poirot, of course!
Oh, I love this post! Especially because I am a huge fan of mysteries! Poirot, Sherlock, Nancy Drew and Miss Maple tops my list 🙂
You took me down memory lane. Great post with a diverse list of books on detective stories. I have read most of the authors/books you have listed here and appreciate the introduction to Bumokesh Bakshi as well as Faluda.
Byomkesh Bakshi and Sherlock Holmes are the best according to me. This really brought back memories of all the detectives.
Thank you for the trip down memory lane. I grew up on a healthy dose of Nancy Drews, Hardy Boys, and of course, Poirot and Miss Marple. Feluda and Byomkesh Bakshi I discovered much later although I do remember the latter in a show on DD.
Thank you for participating in the blog hop, Samata.